Pages

Saturday, November 18, 2023

Poems for Nov. 15-6


Center of the Universe
 by Hannah Emerson:  

To Be a Person by Jane Hirshfield

I was in a Hurry by Dunya Mikhail

The Beautiful Changes by Richard Wilbur

Hamlen Brook by Richard Wilbur

Bread and Butter  by Gayle Brandeis

David Drake -- 3 selections of his inscriptions
fragments inscribed on pots made by David Drake,  https://poets.org/poet/david-drake
I include 3 of them in the poems.  We will NOT be meeting the Wednesday before Thanksgiving.  I hope you will be spending this holiday with friends and family and share together
the blessings of food, shelter, and time to gather together to honor the sake of gathering together. 



DISCUSSION:

Center of the Universe by Hannah Emerson:  This is in her volume of poetry called The Kissing of Kissing.

I started the session with this lovely poem by a young poet, Ben Wilson.
IN THE FOREST

In the forest

a man sits

a tree stands high

a river runs through his silence. —from 2014 Rattle Young Poets Anthology When asked Why do you like to write poetry? Ben replied: “I like writing poetry because it makes me feel like I am in another world and I forget about the normal world.” 
It seemed appropriate to introduce Hannah Emerson whose poem "Listening" we discussed on Oct. 27.

 I also shared I brought up this excellent book, that helps us understand better the negative effect of labeling "disabled" and believe that there is a "normal". What can a body do?(How we Meet the Built World): by Sara Hendren.  For Hannah, she considers poets, "Keepers of the light" and has her on definition of "Hell".  
"It is mine and a great gift of trying to be here.  I help the world-- people need to become me, to help themselves."

discussion comments:  Hannah seems to recording her own "Self ignition".  The poem seems like a dance. 
For sure, her mind is its own place and she provides us a view of its fire -- how "hell" for her is at the heart of creation.  
There were several shares of funny quotes about hell as well -- why would one choose a boring condition of heaven ? (no cigars -- Mark Twain).  Judith brought up the story of Aucassin and Nicolette, where Aucassin declares that he would prefer hell to heaven because hell's inmates are likely to be more entertaining.  (The medieval tale does complete reversals, and in this case is a mockery of Saints Lives.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aucassin_and_Nicolette

To Be a Person by Jane Hirshfield
Normally when we say "person" in contemporary parlance, we are referring to a full "actualized" human being.  Judith brought up the etymology of persona, or the actor's mask.  Hirshfield's opening line is a surprising challenge:  How is being a person "untenable"? Her leaps between stanzas to portray what a person is, works through this "untenable" to consider "it may be possible then, after all".  A delightful play of paradox which ends on a brilliant metaphor of waiting working boots... yes... to be a person, is to be a work in progress... and we joked at the word "open" -- like our group -- how, like an unused drawer to open, we share the joys of discovering surprises we might not find without each other.
Judith thought immediately of Van Gogh "waiting working boots" : 

(I had a different association in my poem about them in my first book, Cadences: Van Gogh’s Boots

Only a pair of boots,

a man’s only pair of boots.

Leather aches into a stiff lip,

chafes the space 

            mangled laces

     barely close —

peasant boots —

            artist’s boots —

mute mates.

 

One pulled up stark

watching the other

lip folded open

as if ready to speak.

 

A painting of boots,

one with a cow-thick tongue

hanging in the bleeding shadows

of a barn,

the other kicked off, 

crumpled in fatigue.

 

The caked spring mud says 

one man has been out 

in the world, walking.

One flung to the bare floor,

empty of sinew and bone,

the other standing upright,

a sentinel

watching over its mate.


I was in a Hurry by Dunya Mikhail

We enjoyed the powerful  recitation by Dunya in Arabic and English to the sound of the Arabic music. 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bPCXnL_AQiA  Note, she says, "glittering with dreams" not "scattered like".

Thank you Rose-Marie who mentioned she found it, recommended by Ilya Kaminsky and his sense of loss of country as Ukranian. 

We all look at the current Gaza-Hamas-Israeli horror, and the complexity of "homeland".  As for our own country, are we not also grieving how it seems "like a broken branch" -- that we haven't been noticing the need to help it?  

Dunya's images paint images of refugees, the urgency of fleeing and this deep ache of longing for what had been home.  Even if bad things happen in it, even if we are not in agreement with its leaders, it is still home.  


Richard Wilbur: 

 “Wilbur’s poems matter not because they may or may not be stylish at any given moment but because they keep the English language alive: Wilbur’s great poems feel as fresh—as astonishing, as perplexing, as shocking—as they did 50 years ago.” -- James Longenbach

 

Wilbur also was an accomplished translator. I find poets who are fluent enough in other languages to be able to translate poetry, tend to be rather fine poets in their native tongue.

Wilbur is no exception.  I love that his dates  (1921-2017) coincide with the life of my own father, who indeed loved his poetry.  Sadly I'll miss the presentation but all are welcome to attend!  Below two of the ones Bob Darling selected (and links to the others.)

The Beautiful Changes: 

What a pleasure to see such deft craftsmanship, the play of the word "changes" as  noun and verb and the implication of "beautiful" as adjective applied to the fact of changes, as well as becoming the abstract noun of The Beautiful.  The liquid l's create a swimming of sound, wading through this summer scene. The use of the verb TUNING, not turning, for the chameleon.  The surprise of "the beautiful" which can change in "such kind ways", bringing in a human element of hand holding something that is not just for oneself... "wishing ever to sunder/things, and things' selves for a second finding" prepares us for the oooo sounds of lose,preceded as they are by  you, blue Lucernes, tune, prove.

As Graeme put it, a nature poem on steroids-- but so beautifully more, plunging into a satisfying depth of thought and feeling. 


Hamlen Brook: 

We reveled in the inventive use of language, the rhymes which dart out and about like the trout, without being overly apparent.  We all agreed flickèd should have been written with the è to indicate saying it as two syllables, suggesting flickered. Was it Elmer who said about rainbow trout-- "don't quarrel about the colors".  Indeed a "flickèd slew of sparks and glittering silt... does the trick, along with the burnished dragon flies.


Jim called on his experience as canoe/kayak enthusiast who confirmed that indeed, especially on a blue-skied day paddling coming up to a stand of birch, it will seem to be a "white precipice."


How to take it all in??? I loved that Wilbur uses the word "trick" -- with Joy!  The poignant ache of it,

like the Portuguese saudade or fado is beautifully told... something we recognize as common, but told in a beautifully uncommon way.


Bread and Butter: 

It seems as if there are two poems here.  The "how did anyone think of this" and know how to do it...

and then a slant love poem ...  

 




No comments: